QFT III
Overview
Section titled “Overview”This course is about the places where quantum field theory stops looking like a formalism for elementary particles and starts looking like a language for phases, defects, geometry, and universality. It begins with the two-dimensional Ising model, where the high-temperature expansion turns the partition function into a sum over closed loops and the low-temperature expansion turns it into a sum over domain walls. Those elementary graphical expansions already contain many of the themes of the course: duality, nonlocal variables, continuum limits, and the emergence of fields from sums over geometrical objects.
From there the course moves through the continuum field theory of critical phenomena, renormalization-group fixed points, scaling dimensions, conformal invariance, the operator product expansion, two-dimensional conformal field theory, Virasoro symmetry, null states, and minimal models. The Ising model returns not as a lattice system but as a conformal field theory with spin, disorder, energy, and fermion operators fitting into a rigid algebraic structure.
The later parts of the course widen the lens. Gauge fields, Wilson loops, worldline and worldsheet path integrals, conformal anomalies, random lattices, random surfaces, superfluidity, compact phases, vortices, monopoles, solitons, and confinement appear as different ways in which quantum fields encode extended objects. The final pages point toward strings, branes, sigma models, and geometric beta functions. The goal is not to make all of these subjects look identical; it is to make their shared mechanisms visible.
The organizing principle is: a quantum field theory is understood by its observables, its defects, and its scaling limits. Local Lagrangians are important, but they are not the whole story. Dual variables, disorder operators, Wilson loops, monopole gases, random surfaces, and worldsheet degrees of freedom often reveal the physics more directly than the original microscopic variables.
For a first pass, begin with Ising Model and Graphical Expansions. The reading routes support more focused study, and the lesson list gives the full sequence. Use the warm-ups to check your preparation.
Acknowledgement
Section titled “Acknowledgement”These webpages are based on handwritten notes taken by Jie Ren from Alexander M. Polyakov’s one-semester course Selected Topics in High-Energy Physics. The notes have been edited, expanded, typeset, supplemented with derivations and figures, and adapted for QFT.org.
Any errors in transcription, interpretation, exposition, convention choices, or notation are the responsibility of the editor of these webpages.
Scope of the reconstruction
Section titled “Scope of the reconstruction”The handwritten source is compact: it records formulas, diagrams, changes of subject, and short physical prompts rather than a self-contained transcript. The forty numbered lessons on this site are therefore editorial teaching units, not a claim that the source records forty class meetings. Their order preserves the notebook’s main progression—from lattice expansions and critical fields through conformal methods, extended observables, random surfaces, compact defects, and string geometry—but some recurring topics are gathered so that prerequisites appear before they are used.
Material added for exposition includes intermediate algebra, convention checks, figures, exercises with solutions, and links between ideas that are only juxtaposed in the source. Such additions are intended to explain the course’s reasoning, not to attribute new wording or claims to Polyakov. In particular, the string, brane, and AdS material near the end should be read at the level stated on the relevant pages: some results are derived, while others are explicitly structural hints.
Exact results and approximations
Section titled “Exact results and approximations”These notes deliberately move between exact lattice identities, continuum scaling arguments, conformal algebra, semiclassical defect sums, and string-theoretic intuition. Those modes of reasoning should not be read with the same level of literalness. The following dictionary is used throughout the course.
| Label or phrase | How to read it | Typical examples |
|---|---|---|
| Exact identity | An equality inside a stated model and convention. | Kramers–Wannier duality, finite-lattice disorder-line deformations, Ward identities, contour-mode commutators. |
| Controlled approximation | A result within a stated expansion and regime. | One-loop RG near four dimensions; sigma-model backgrounds with curvature radii and variation lengths large compared with . |
| Semiclassical mechanism | A saddle-point or dilute-gas explanation whose regime must be checked. | Kinks, vortices, monopole plasmas, dual-photon mass generation, area-law estimates. |
| Structural hint | A conceptual bridge rather than a derivation from earlier pages. | Proposed gauge/string or holographic identifications, random-surface intuition, brane language. |
Local convention notes matter. In particular, factors of , signs in Euclidean continuation, normalizations of , and definitions of compact gauge fields vary across the literature. When a formula is convention-sensitive, the page states the convention before using it.
Prerequisites
Section titled “Prerequisites”Required background. QFT I supplies the needed command of path integrals, Green functions, perturbation theory, conserved currents, gauge fields, Ward identities, and one-loop renormalization. Readers should also be comfortable with dimensional analysis, Wick rotation, and spontaneous symmetry breaking. The opening lessons develop the Ising expansions themselves, so prior mastery of the Ising model is not required.
Helpful background. Selected parts of QFT II provide a useful first encounter with Wilsonian RG, operator products, two-dimensional field theory, sigma models, instantons, monopoles, and confinement. QFT II and QFT III deliberately overlap, so it is reasonable to consult those topics in parallel rather than treating every QFT II lesson as a strict prerequisite. Statistical mechanics—especially partition functions, correlation length, critical exponents, and transfer-matrix reasoning—is also helpful. Readers unsure of their preparation can use the site’s readiness guide before beginning.
The mathematical tools used most often are complex analysis, distributions, Gaussian integration, saddle-point methods, representation theory of Lie algebras, contour integrals, homotopy intuition, and elementary differential geometry. The notes review the relevant pieces when they become central, but readers will get more out of the course if they are comfortable moving between algebraic, analytic, and geometric arguments.
How to read these notes
Section titled “How to read these notes”The safest route is linear. Lessons 01–08 build the statistical-mechanics core: Ising expansions, Kramers–Wannier duality, continuum limits, disorder operators, and Ising fermions. Lessons 09–16 connect that core to relativistic fields, scaling, the OPE, and finite conformal transformations. Lessons 17–20 are a bridge rather than a single CFT block: they develop real-time correlators, currents, Ward identities, stress tensors, Goldstone reasoning, QED, and the two-dimensional Thirring model. Virasoro theory begins in earnest at lesson 21; lessons 21–29 then build through null states and minimal models to the Ising CFT.
Lessons 30–35 pivot from local operators to extended objects: worldlines, worldsheets, conformal gauge, anomalies, gauge-invariant observables, and random surfaces. Lessons 36–39 develop superfluid phases, vortices, compact gauge fields, solitons, monopole plasmas, and confinement. Lesson 40 asks what worldsheet consistency constrains about a candidate spacetime. It derives sigma-model and free-string tests, then separately calculates AdS dilation and scalar boundary powers; it does not derive a gauge/string duality.
A first reading should follow the lead, subject-specific sections, and stated checks on each page; use the local prerequisite notes when a lesson points backward. A second reading should include the exercises and the derivations of Ward identities, OPE constraints, duality relations, and area-law estimates. Many formulas become more transparent after drawing the object they count: loops, contours, worldsheets, vortices, or Wilson surfaces.
Reading routes
Section titled “Reading routes”The linear route is best for a first pass, but the course also supports targeted reading.
| Goal | Suggested route | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Learn critical phenomena and RG | 01–06, then 12–15 | Separate exact lattice rewritings, continuum matching, perturbative RG, and fixed-point kinematics. |
| Learn the Ising-to-CFT story | 01–16, then 21–29 | Track how , , , and change meaning from lattice observables to scaling fields. |
| Understand conformal machinery | 12–16, then 21–29 | Separate global conformal symmetry, Virasoro symmetry, and null-vector constraints. |
| Follow gauge-invariant observables | 11, 19–20, 30–31, 34, then 37–40 | Lesson 31 supplies the worldsheet constraints used in 40; lessons 37–38 supply the compact-defect background for 39. |
| Study defects and confinement | 07–08, then 36–39 | Compare Ising disorder lines, vortices in compact phases, and monopoles in compact gauge theory; the dimensions and defects are different. |
| Reach the string/surface viewpoint | 30–35, then 37–40 | Use 37–38 for the compact-angle and gauge-field background before 39. Distinguish regulated surface sums, continuum strings and the separate AdS calculation. |
Lesson list
Section titled “Lesson list”Part I — Ising model, duality, and continuum limits
Section titled “Part I — Ising model, duality, and continuum limits”- Ising Model and Graphical Expansions develops the high-temperature loop expansion, the low-temperature domain-wall expansion, and the entropy–energy competition behind phase transitions.
- Kramers–Wannier Duality and Mean-Field Theory derives the dual coupling relation, identifies the self-dual point, and compares exact duality logic with mean-field intuition.
- Hubbard–Stratonovich Transformation and the Continuum Field turns spin interactions into an auxiliary field and explains how the continuum description emerges.
- Critical Propagators and the Upper Critical Dimension studies lattice kernels, correlation length, loop divergences, and the special role of four dimensions.
- Epsilon Expansion and One-Loop Scaling introduces dimensions, beta functions, and the Wilson–Fisher fixed point.
- Fixed Points, Tricriticality, and Order–Disorder Variables organizes relevant perturbations, tricritical behavior, and the first appearance of order and disorder variables.
- Disorder Lines, Branch Cuts, and Defect Operators explains disorder-line insertions as branch cuts and interprets them as defect operators.
- Order–Disorder Duality and Ising Fermions shows how order–disorder composites lead naturally to fermionic variables in the Ising continuum limit.
Part II — Relativistic fields, scaling, and conformal symmetry
Section titled “Part II — Relativistic fields, scaling, and conformal symmetry”- Relativistic Fields, Spinors, and the Ising Continuum Limit connects free scalar, vector, and spinor fields to the continuum Ising description.
- Lattice Dirac Equations and Euclidean Spinors develops lattice Green functions, Euclidean spinor conventions, and the continuum Dirac equation.
- Z₂ Gauge Systems, Wilson Loops, and Free Correlators introduces lattice gauge variables, Wilson loops, and basic free-field correlators.
- Scaling Dimensions, Correlators, and Critical Exponents derives scaling forms for correlation functions and relates anomalous dimensions to critical behavior.
- Callan–Symanzik Scaling and Emergent Conformal Symmetry explains RG equations for Green functions and the route from scale invariance to conformal invariance.
- Conformal Transformations in d Dimensions derives conformal Killing equations, inversions, and the covariance of correlators in general dimension.
- OPE, Associativity, and Conformal Correlators introduces the operator product expansion, conformal three-point data, cross ratios, and associativity constraints.
- Finite Conformal Maps, Gauge Symmetry, and Free Fields studies finite conformal maps, primary transformations, gauge analogies, and free-field mode setups.
Part III — Free fields, currents, and Ward identities
Section titled “Part III — Free fields, currents, and Ward identities”- Free Fields, Wightman Functions, and the iε Prescription derives Wightman functions, Feynman functions, analyticity, and the prescription.
- Commutators, Currents, and Ward Identities relates causal commutators, current conservation, and Ward identities.
- Stress Tensors, Goldstone Modes, and QED Ward Identities develops stress tensors, spacetime symmetries, Goldstone logic, and transversality in QED.
- Two-Dimensional QED, the Thirring Model, and Currents studies two-dimensional gauge dynamics, current–current interactions, and chiral-current structures.
Part IV — Virasoro symmetry, null states, and minimal models
Section titled “Part IV — Virasoro symmetry, null states, and minimal models”- Stress-Tensor OPE and Conformal Ward Identities derives the singular terms in stress-tensor OPEs and translates contour integrals into conformal Ward identities.
- Primary Fields, Cylinder Maps, and Mode Expansions maps the plane to the cylinder and relates primary-field transformations to stress-tensor modes.
- Virasoro Generators, Descendants, and Central Charge constructs descendant states, the OPE, and the central extension of conformal symmetry.
- Schwarzian Derivative and the Virasoro Algebra explains the anomalous transformation of the stress tensor and derives the Schwarzian term.
- Global Conformal Generators and Descendant States isolates the global conformal subgroup and studies descendant towers under .
- Null States and BPZ Differential Equations derives null-vector decoupling and the resulting differential equations for correlation functions.
- Degenerate Fields, Kac Labels, and Constraints introduces degenerate representations, Kac labels, and restrictions on dimensions and central charge.
- Minimal Models, Fusion, and the Ising Operator Algebra builds the minimal-model spectrum, fusion rules, and the Ising operator algebra.
- Ising CFT, Majorana Fermions, and Tricritical Extensions connects the Ising CFT to Majorana fermions and previews tricritical and superconformal extensions.
Part V — Worldlines, worldsheets, anomalies, and random surfaces
Section titled “Part V — Worldlines, worldsheets, anomalies, and random surfaces”- Superconformal Currents, Maxwell Lines, and Worldline Actions transitions from conformal currents to Maxwell line intuition and relativistic worldline actions.
- Worldlines, Worldsheets, and Reparametrization Gauge compares point-particle and string actions, gauge fixing, induced metrics, and stress-tensor constraints.
- Conformal Gauge, Two-Dimensional Gravity, and Vacuum Polarization develops local conformal gauge, metric-source response, and Ward identities including contact terms.
- Conformal Anomalies, Liouville Action, and Nonlocal Effective Actions derives the anomaly action and finite Weyl variation with the inverse-operator domain and closed-surface zero mode specified.
- Gauge-Invariant Observables and Asymptotic Amplitudes distinguishes physical observables from gauge-dependent fields, using intrinsic distance and qualified asymptotic amplitudes as examples.
- Random Lattices, Matrix Models, and Random Surfaces develops ribbon graphs, planar resolvents and area-counting criticality, distinguishing the formal quartic map expansion from a convergent matrix integral.
Part VI — Defects, confinement, strings, and geometry
Section titled “Part VI — Defects, confinement, strings, and geometry”- Superfluidity, Landau Criterion, and Accelerated Frames derives the Landau emission threshold, phase stiffness and response, with separate rotating and accelerated-frame examples.
- Compact Phases, Vortices, and Duality develops winding, vortex gases and screening, separating thermal BKT physics from three-dimensional Euclidean duality and its restricted quantum-rotor interpretation.
- Compact Gauge Fields, Higgsing, Solitons, and Topological Defects studies compact connections, probe charges, Higgs masses, localized kink modes, vortices and monopoles, distinguishing topology from stability.
- Wilson Loops, Worldlines, Monopole Plasma, and Confinement connects static-source projection, the leading strong-coupling sheet and a controlled monopole plasma to a continuous dual wall, with probe and screening limits.
- Strings, Branes, Sigma Models, and AdS Hints develops classical metric elimination, metric RG versus Weyl consistency, free-string vertex conditions and annulus channels, then separately derives AdS scalar boundary powers.
Formula and convention quick index
Section titled “Formula and convention quick index”This table is meant for readers returning to the course as a reference. It points to the first page where each convention or formula is developed with context.
| Topic | First detailed appearance |
|---|---|
| High-temperature closed-loop expansion | 01 |
| Kramers–Wannier duality relation | 02 |
| Hubbard–Stratonovich effective action | 03 |
| Ornstein–Zernike critical propagator | 04 |
| Wilson–Fisher beta function and expansion | 05 |
| Disorder-line endpoint and branch-cut convention | 07 |
| Ising Majorana continuum dictionary | 08, 09 |
| Scaling dimensions and thermodynamic exponents | 12 |
| Conformal Killing equation and finite conformal maps | 14, 16 |
| OPE and crossing/associativity | 15 |
| Wightman, Feynman, commutator, and retarded functions | 17, 18 |
| Stress-tensor OPE and Virasoro algebra | 21, 23, 24 |
| BPZ null-state equation and Kac labels | 26, 27 |
| Ising and tricritical Ising operator algebras | 28, 29 |
| Worldline reparametrization and proper time | 30 |
| Nambu–Goto and Polyakov worldsheet actions | 31, 40 |
| Domain-qualified anomaly action and finite Weyl variation | 32, 33 |
| Matrix-model genus counting and random surfaces | 35 |
| BKT vortices and compact-phase duality | 37 |
| Compact gauge fields, monopoles, and Wilson-loop area laws | 38, 39 |
| Worldsheet consistency tests and AdS scalar boundary powers | 40 |
Notation and conventions
Section titled “Notation and conventions”These notes inherit the site-wide natural units and mostly-minus Lorentzian metric,
Euclidean calculations use a positive metric and the weight ; pages that cross between signatures state the continuation locally. Statistical-mechanics systems are usually written with Boltzmann weights
or, after passing to a Euclidean field description,
For the ferromagnetic nearest-neighbor Ising model, the default convention is
so
The square-lattice Kramers–Wannier dual coupling is written as
The continuum scalar theory near an Ising-type critical point is normalized as
where is the temperature-like relevant coupling. The dots denote all operators compatible with the symmetries; most are irrelevant near the Wilson–Fisher fixed point.
A local scaling operator of dimension transforms under the active dilation used in this course as
The equivalent passive convention is and ; do not combine its prefactor with the active argument. For separated scalar primaries in the conformally invariant flat-space Euclidean vacuum,
when the dimensions match and the operators have compatible quantum numbers. The OPE convention is
with spin-dependent tensor structures suppressed when the context is scalar.
Scaling dimensions and OPE data characterize the fixed point, with operator normalizations specified. Beta functions describe the flow in chosen coupling coordinates and a renormalization scheme; they are not themselves scheme-independent fixed-point data.
In two Euclidean dimensions we use
The holomorphic stress tensor is expanded as
and the Virasoro algebra is
For a primary field of weights ,
In the charged Abelian sections, the convention is
with
With Hermitian generators, Wilson loops are written as
where the connection includes the coupling in this formula. Pages using a canonical gauge field, a dimensionless compact connection, or adjoint-vector notation state the corresponding local normalization before use.
A perimeter law means , while an area law means
For a specified probe representation, an asymptotic area law diagnoses a nonzero string tension when screening does not remove the long flux tube. Extract the static energy at zero temperature from a long rectangular loop, taking the time extent to infinity at fixed separation and requiring nonzero overlap with the lowest state in that source sector; then study large separation. Even a pure gauge theory can screen some representations. Perimeter terms alone also do not exhaust nonconfining behavior: a Coulomb interaction gives shape-dependent contributions. Lesson 39 develops these distinctions.
Compact scalar phases obey
Here is the angular one-form obtained from local real lifts, integrated around an oriented closed loop avoiding defect cores. A nonzero winding forbids a single-valued real lift on the whole loop; a branch cut only chooses coordinates for that lift.
For the positive Euclidean worldsheet and target geometry used in lessons 31 and 40, the kinetic Polyakov action is
where is the independent worldsheet metric, , and is the positive target metric. Reserve for the induced metric. The string tension is
For a nondegenerate immersion, eliminating the auxiliary metric from this classical kinetic action gives the area action. Quantum Weyl consistency imposes additional conditions; it does not follow from classical elimination.
Diagnostic warm-ups
Section titled “Diagnostic warm-ups”These short problems test the background assumptions for the course. They are not barriers to entry; they simply flag mechanisms that will return often.
Warm-up 1: closed loops in the high-temperature Ising expansion
Section titled “Warm-up 1: closed loops in the high-temperature Ising expansion”Use
for each nearest-neighbor bond of the Ising model. Show that after summing over all spins, only subgraphs in which every vertex has even degree contribute.
Solution
Expanding the product over bonds chooses some set of occupied bonds. The contribution of contains
At a site , the spin appears once for every occupied bond ending at . If that number is , then the spin sum contains
This equals when is even and when is odd. Therefore a graph contributes only if all vertices have even degree. On the square lattice this means the occupied bonds form closed loops, possibly with intersections.
Warm-up 2: the upper critical dimension of φ⁴ theory
Section titled “Warm-up 2: the upper critical dimension of φ⁴ theory”In Euclidean dimensions, use
to find the engineering dimension of . Then find the engineering dimension of in
What dimension makes marginal by power counting?
Solution
The Euclidean action is dimensionless in natural units. Since and , the kinetic term gives
Thus
For the interaction,
so
The coupling is marginal at . This is why is the upper critical dimension of the Ising universality class described by scalar theory.
Warm-up 3: a contour generator in two-dimensional CFT
Section titled “Warm-up 3: a contour generator in two-dimensional CFT”Let
and define
Take and define the radial commutator by subtracting an inner from an outer counterclockwise contour about the origin, with between their radii. Assume the swept annulus contains no other insertion, pole or cut. Derive the infinitesimal action of on for integer .
Solution
The outer-minus-inner difference deforms to a small counterclockwise circle about that excludes zero. This gives
Using the singular terms in the OPE,
The simple pole gives . The double pole gives the derivative of at :
Therefore
This is the local form of the conformal transformation generated by . Keeping ensures that the Laurent weight is analytic on the small circle’s disk even when .
Further reading
Section titled “Further reading”The lesson pages cite sources where they are used. The following uncited companions are useful for the course as a whole:
- John Cardy, Scaling and Renormalization in Statistical Physics (Cambridge University Press, 1996).
- Sidney Coleman, Aspects of Symmetry: Selected Erice Lectures (Cambridge University Press, 1985).
- Philippe Di Francesco, Pierre Mathieu, and David Sénéchal, Conformal Field Theory (Springer, 1997).
- Michael E. Peskin and Daniel V. Schroeder, An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory (Addison-Wesley, 1995).
- Joseph Polchinski, String Theory, Volume 1: An Introduction to the Bosonic String (Cambridge University Press, 1998).
- Alexander M. Polyakov, Gauge Fields and Strings (Harwood Academic Publishers, 1987).
- Steven Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields, Volume I: Foundations (Cambridge University Press, 1995) and Volume II: Modern Applications (Cambridge University Press, 1996).
- Jean Zinn-Justin, Quantum Field Theory and Critical Phenomena, 4th ed. (Clarendon Press, 2002).
Original QFT.org content:CC BY 4.0, unless an item supplies different terms. Third-party material retains its own terms.