{
  "title": "Representative claim domains and validity boundaries for Quantum-Gravity Consistency and Swampland",
  "table_id": "quantum-gravity-consistency-and-swampland-claim-domain-table",
  "columns": [
    {
      "key": "claim_object",
      "label": "Claim object"
    },
    {
      "key": "state_ensemble_and_conventions",
      "label": "State, ensemble, and conventions"
    },
    {
      "key": "approximation_status_and_evidence_timing",
      "label": "Approximation, status, and evidence timing"
    },
    {
      "key": "uncertainty_and_counterevidence",
      "label": "Uncertainty and counterevidence"
    },
    {
      "key": "falsifier",
      "label": "Falsifier"
    },
    {
      "key": "failure_condition",
      "label": "Failure condition"
    },
    {
      "key": "licensed_conclusion",
      "label": "Licensed conclusion"
    }
  ],
  "records": [
    {
      "claim_object": {
        "text": "no global symmetry",
        "html": "no global symmetry"
      },
      "state_ensemble_and_conventions": {
        "text": "Declare exact AdS/CFT or other stated premise; use the volume conventions unless the page states a local replacement.",
        "html": "Declare exact AdS/CFT or other stated premise; use the volume conventions unless the page states a local replacement."
      },
      "approximation_status_and_evidence_timing": {
        "text": "Conditional theorem or structural result. Control chain: quantum-gravity premise and black holes → charge, tower, and moduli constraints → examples and conditional derivations → counterexamples and dated tests → typed consistency claim. Sources are cited on the destination page; literature checked through 10 August 2026.",
        "html": "Conditional theorem or structural result. Control chain: quantum-gravity premise and black holes → charge, tower, and moduli constraints → examples and conditional derivations → counterexamples and dated tests → typed consistency claim. Sources are cited on the destination page; literature checked through 10 August 2026."
      },
      "uncertainty_and_counterevidence": {
        "text": "Track omitted corrections, alternate branches, and competing definitions. A failed “boundary current and bulk gauge check” check is counterevidence to the promoted claim.",
        "html": "Track omitted corrections, alternate branches, and competing definitions. A failed “boundary current and bulk gauge check” check is counterevidence to the promoted claim."
      },
      "falsifier": {
        "text": "boundary current and bulk gauge check",
        "html": "boundary current and bulk gauge check"
      },
      "failure_condition": {
        "text": "an assumption-free theorem about all gravity",
        "html": "an assumption-free theorem about all gravity"
      },
      "licensed_conclusion": {
        "text": "a conditional result in that framework",
        "html": "a conditional result in that framework"
      }
    },
    {
      "claim_object": {
        "text": "weak gravity or distance conjecture",
        "html": "weak gravity or distance conjecture"
      },
      "state_ensemble_and_conventions": {
        "text": "Declare charge normalization or moduli metric; use the volume conventions unless the page states a local replacement.",
        "html": "Declare charge normalization or moduli metric; use the volume conventions unless the page states a local replacement."
      },
      "approximation_status_and_evidence_timing": {
        "text": "Named conjecture under stated hypotheses. Control chain: quantum-gravity premise and black holes → charge, tower, and moduli constraints → examples and conditional derivations → counterexamples and dated tests → typed consistency claim. Sources are cited on the destination page; literature checked through 10 August 2026.",
        "html": "Named conjecture under stated hypotheses. Control chain: quantum-gravity premise and black holes → charge, tower, and moduli constraints → examples and conditional derivations → counterexamples and dated tests → typed consistency claim. Sources are cited on the destination page; literature checked through 10 August 2026."
      },
      "uncertainty_and_counterevidence": {
        "text": "Track omitted corrections, alternate branches, and competing definitions. A failed “extremality, towers, and examples” check is counterevidence to the promoted claim.",
        "html": "Track omitted corrections, alternate branches, and competing definitions. A failed “extremality, towers, and examples” check is counterevidence to the promoted claim."
      },
      "falsifier": {
        "text": "extremality, towers, and examples",
        "html": "extremality, towers, and examples"
      },
      "failure_condition": {
        "text": "a proven universal inequality",
        "html": "a proven universal inequality"
      },
      "licensed_conclusion": {
        "text": "a named conjectural constraint",
        "html": "a named conjectural constraint"
      }
    },
    {
      "claim_object": {
        "text": "de Sitter or landscape claim",
        "html": "de Sitter or landscape claim"
      },
      "state_ensemble_and_conventions": {
        "text": "Declare compactification and EFT assumptions; use the volume conventions unless the page states a local replacement.",
        "html": "Declare compactification and EFT assumptions; use the volume conventions unless the page states a local replacement."
      },
      "approximation_status_and_evidence_timing": {
        "text": "Model-specific calculation or conditional result. Control chain: quantum-gravity premise and black holes → charge, tower, and moduli constraints → examples and conditional derivations → counterexamples and dated tests → typed consistency claim. Sources are cited on the destination page; literature checked through 10 August 2026.",
        "html": "Model-specific calculation or conditional result. Control chain: quantum-gravity premise and black holes → charge, tower, and moduli constraints → examples and conditional derivations → counterexamples and dated tests → typed consistency claim. Sources are cited on the destination page; literature checked through 10 August 2026."
      },
      "uncertainty_and_counterevidence": {
        "text": "Track omitted corrections, alternate branches, and competing definitions. A failed “controlled examples and counterexamples” check is counterevidence to the promoted claim.",
        "html": "Track omitted corrections, alternate branches, and competing definitions. A failed “controlled examples and counterexamples” check is counterevidence to the promoted claim."
      },
      "falsifier": {
        "text": "controlled examples and counterexamples",
        "html": "controlled examples and counterexamples"
      },
      "failure_condition": {
        "text": "settled absence of all vacua",
        "html": "settled absence of all vacua"
      },
      "licensed_conclusion": {
        "text": "a dated conditional exclusion or obstruction",
        "html": "a dated conditional exclusion or obstruction"
      }
    }
  ],
  "scope": "Exact structured equivalent of the reader-facing semantic table; column order, cell text, and source HTML are preserved."
}